• Welcome to BookAndReader!

    We LOVE books and hope you'll join us in sharing your favorites and experiences along with your love of reading with our community. Registering for our site is free and easy, just CLICK HERE!

    Already a member and forgot your password? Click here.

Feedback for a Writer about to present to a publisher

Just Jo

New Member
Dear Readers

Please could you help me with some honest feedback for a new writer who is about to present to a big publisher. There are 5 synopsises below, are the stories engaging, would you read the sleeve and say I d like to read this book, or share your advice on how we can make it better!

01 - Chase
Henri Chase, a soldier, presumed killed in action returns from the dead only to find his world has been turned upside down.
His wife is dead, committed suicide and his daughter had disappeared into the fostering system. Several years after the search for his daughter began she is killed in a tragic accident. All hope of reclaiming anything from the wreckage of his old life are gone, forever.

Five years on, the demons still plague his every waking moment, but in those dark years an urban legend was born.
A man, a predator, a killer was hunting. His Domain, the streets of London. His prey, the thieves, drug dealers, rapists, murderers and anyone else reaping rewards from ill gotten gains or preying on the helpless. But in these violent acts of punishment he was becoming what he hunted, what he hated.
Fate is about give him second chance, redemption and a opportunity to turn his back on the road he had taken.

Following an alcohol and drug fuelled assault on a drug deal, Chase drops his guard and is picked up by an unknown security team lead by a man from is past.
The options were simple - be tried for his crimes, which would ultimately mean lifetime imprisonment or full cooperation in hunting down a pending threat on London.

Through hallucinations, dreams, and memories we will learn of Chase's time in the army, his wife and daughter. We will meet the Good man who still hides in the shadows of his own mind.


02 - Rough Riders
Struck by the Californian gold rush, William Fredrick Cody left his Iowa home two months before is 15th birthday. His head, filled with dreams of fame and fortune to support his widowed mother.
A care free boy, trying desperately hard to fill his fathers shoes.

A chance meeting with a Pony Express agent James Butler would change his life, forever.

Wanted.
Young, Skinny, Wiry Fellows not over eighteen.
Must be expert riders, willing to risk death daily

A story of adventure,fear, and growing up with his life long friend Billy Tate, who became an inspiration and embodiment of true brotherhood. Told through the eyes of an aged circus cowboy, we will relive William's journey from care free boy to the young man who became the legend, Buffalo Bill



04 - After Hours
'Good morning Malibu. Some of you good people are at home with loved ones, some of you are working the night shift walking the beat in the Bay Area or hauling a heavy load long distance outta state. It's midnight thirty, I'm Jamie Davenport, here with you til the sun comes up or the radio goes down'

Her father, a ex Private Investigator, her mother a revered lawyer.
Jamie was destined to be a voice of the people, a rebellious young journalist who just can't turn a blind eye.

Join Jamie's journey in setting the world to rights in her own irrepressible way.
Aided by a father who isn't ready to hang up his hat and a mother who does know best.

No subject too tough, no law unchallenged, no door she won't kick down.
Stepping out from behind the mic, Jamie deals head on with real life and the dark side of today's society.

She'll be with you 'til the sun comes up or the radio goes down.


05 - Tunnel Rats
"Non gratin anus roddentum" - Not worth a rats ass. US 25th Infantry motto.

Private Jonathan 'Cookie' Lewis faced a battle far greater than any challenge he'd endured during the Vietnam war.
Traumatised by a disastrous mission that resulted in fatal injuries and life changing wounds to the 25th Infantry.

How could he go back? back into the darkness, the damp claustrophobic tunnels that just took three more of his friends.
Cookie Lewis had to fight every natural urge to run, if they knew he'd lost his nerve he'd be out on the next transport home.
This was not an option. He was part of the regiment and wouldn't turn his back on them.
They may not mean a rats ass to the rest of the army, but to each other they were brothers.
The brotherhood of war is stronger than life itself.

The story of one mans journey serving in a special team of Infantrymen, the unsung heroes of the Vietnam war, The Tunnel Rats.
 
Last edited:
I'm assuming you mean these as queries and not synopsis. Synopsis are much longer and detailed.

My big concern with all these is they read a bit choppy and difficult to follow.

If you are writing queries to submit keep them simpler with less jumping. Give a summation of the plot without revealing
the end while hooking your reader in.

The one I like best is the last one but it should mention he was a tunnel rat earlier int he blurb.
 
T
I'm assuming you mean these as queries and not synopsis. Synopsis are much longer and detailed.

My big concern with all these is they read a bit choppy and difficult to follow.

If you are writing queries to submit keep them simpler with less jumping. Give a summation of the plot without revealing
the end while hooking your reader in.

The one I like best is the last one but it should mention he was a tunnel rat earlier int he blurb.


Thank you so much for your feedback, it's truly valuable, do you have any examples of queries you have written or more tips please

Just Jo
 
Here is the query letter I used for one of my mg novels


BILLY AND THE GARGOYLES is a 23, 000 mg novel. Angry over his parents’ divorce, and moving to New York City, ten-year-old Billy looks around his new room in disgust. Billy’s mother has her dream job but he has lost contact with his father and misses him. Outside his bedroom windows are a sweltering city he doesn't want to be in and two ugly, stone gargoyles. At first Billy doesn’t like the silent sentries, but he is lonely and confides in them. As he talks to them, they wake from their stone sleep.

With members of their own family missing, the gargoyles understand Billy’s loneliness and the three become fast friends. When he learns his mother’s real estate developer boyfriend is responsible for the gargoyles' disappearance, Billy is devastated and fears losing his new friends. He is surprised to learn the gargoyles were not destroyed but moved. He is determined to help reunite the gargoyles and along the way, he learns there are times when letting go is best.

I hope you will be interested in reading BILLY AND THE GARGOYLES. I look forward to hearing from you. Thank you
for your time and consideration.
 
First of all, most major publishers will not accept queries from writers, only agents. You need to get an agent. You haven't said, but this appears to be a story anthology, which are very difficult to get published except those of famous writers.
Blurbs should be in present tense an remain consistent. You move from present tense (is) to past (was) and future (could) in all of these descriptions. Also, watch out for incomplete sentences and typos. For example:

02 - Rough Riders
Struck by the Californian gold rush, William Fredrick Cody LEAVES his Iowa home two months before HIS 15th birthday. His head, filled with dreams of fame and fortune to support his widowed mother. (Incomplete sentence)
A care free boy, trying desperately hard to fill his fathers shoes. (Incomplete)
A chance meeting with a Pony Express agent, James Butler, WILL change his life, forever. (Without commas, this is not a sentence.)
Wanted.
Young, Skinny, Wiry Fellows not over eighteen.
Must be expert riders, willing to risk death daily (PERIOD)
A story of adventure, (SPACE) fear, and growing up with his life long friend Billy Tate, who BECOMES an inspiration and embodiment of true brotherhood. The reader will relive William's journey from care free boy to the young man who BECOMES the legend, Buffalo Bill, AS told through the eyes of an aged circus cowboy (PERIOD)


You need an editor. This one example tells an agent or publisher that you are "not ready for prime-time." He (or she) will assume, since you did not take the time to perfect your query, that your novel will be an editorial nightmare.

I don't mean to put you down, this comes under your question, "or share your advice on how we can make it better!" Many authors need someone to edit their work and queries. If you can't afford an editor, post on writing forums for help or maybe get a good beta-reader. I tell this to many newer writers, with the hope that criticism from me is better than an agent throwing your submission into the trash.

Hope this advice helps,

JohnB
 
Dear John, thank you so much, this is truly valuable feedback, it's wonderful that you took the time to share so much detail. If you have anymore advice or recommendations we will accept them readily

Thanks John your a true gentleman !!!!
 
Thank you for your nice reply. You probably wouldn't believe how many times I've been attacked when giving constructive criticism. Without such criticism toward me in the past, I'd be a much worse writer.
 
Hi John

We are trying to get this right, so we see this as valuable learning, all tips gratefully received

Just Jo
 
Back
Top