• Welcome to BookAndReader!

    We LOVE books and hope you'll join us in sharing your favorites and experiences along with your love of reading with our community. Registering for our site is free and easy, just CLICK HERE!

    Already a member and forgot your password? Click here.

Saul Bellow: Herzog

direstraits

Well-Known Member
Finished this last week. A very difficult piece, not just to read, but to talk about. There are instances where Bellow seemed to be describing things that I was feeling or thinking that I couldn't have put it any better myself.

The story's depressing as heck. I made the mistake of trying to unwind after a hard day's work with this baby, and I almost opened a vein wallowing in the sense of utter defeat (but I was driving, so I suppose I was just kidding).

I'll write something a little more coherent later, I suppose.
 
I'll write something a little more coherent later, I suppose.

Hi DS!
I started, but only got part way. I'll be very interested in hearing what you have to say.
So far, for me, it is one of those someday-I'll-have-to-finish-this books.
Cheers
:flowers:
 
For me too this was a more difficult book to read - and complete. And once completed it paid put to any more efforts of reading Bellow.

This is not to say that it is a bad book - just a trying one
 
Hi DS!
No sweat. No problem. Whenever. :)
It had slipped my mind also but, as you are still the first whom I have seen with something good to say about this book (within my severly limited vision, of course), I am still curious about your reactions. Bellow still remains an author without a completed book on my list -- I think, :innocent:.

Best of all, though, it is very good to hear from you! /high fives/
How's life?
Cheers
Peder
:flowers:
 
I think the best (and saddest) part of the book is when he goes with the gun to Maddie's house... and doesn't shoot her.
 
My thoughts on Herzog, by Saul Bellow

This isn't an easy book to read, and it isn't easy to write about. This is usually the sort of book that I stay away from in the best of days, as it didn't exactly promise to be an exciting ride. The subject matter is dire like heck. But its reputation as one of the best books ever written precedes it. When the opportunity presented itself I thought it too good a deal to pass up, so I may as well learn what the fuss is about.

The story revolves around one Moses E Herzog, who at the point of the story has come out from his second marriage. The divorce ended badly, and his now ex-wife, Madeleine, shacked up with his supposedly best buddy Valentine, and he's pissed. Also, amidst this emotional turmoil he's suddenly consumed with remorse over the fact that his second child Junie will be growing up without him. All this culminates in a scene where he attempts to confront Maddy when he learned that Junie was apparently mistreated during an argument with Valentine. The manner of his attempted confrontation and subsequent fallout from that forms the climax of the novel.

The unique component of this novel is Herzog's imaginary letter writing - missives he composes to people living or dead covering all manner of things, from his emotions to politics, all revolving around his crumbling life. Sort of the novel's way of revealing Herzog's character growth.

So it's a botched marriage by a has-been, and a plot to regain his self-esteem and child. What's so hard about that? The thing is Bellow's writing is quite precise when it comes to the emotions. The thoughts that run through his mind, especially during the first quarter of the novel, are raw emotions, complete with self-rationalization of what has happened. Anger at Madeleine and how he felt he was unfairly treated in the lead-up to the divorce were quite believable. There were parts in the prose where I thought Herzog described what I personally felt during various stages of disharmony in my own marriage. I'm still married, and nothing in the story even closely reflected what happened in my own life, so no, this didn't feel autobiographical. But there are times when husband and wife are fighting (as all marriages will do) thoughts of who's right and wrong cannot be suppressed, and I felt Bellow captured that accurately. Not that that's very surprising, considering that Bellow himself divorced his second wife, who had an affair with Bellow's long-time friend.

So really the resonance I felt early in the book carried me along. The story plodded in places, and the writing, while excellent, tended to ramble. Still, this wasn't utter boredom ala Bridesheads Revisited, and for that I was thankful.

This is one book that I will probably revisit later on, which is more than I can say for the majority of the books I read, good or bad.
 
Hi DS!
Best of all, though, it is very good to hear from you! /high fives/
How's life?
Peder, it's always great to see you. I'm well, but have been quite busy with work. Although that has tapered down somewhat, and I'm free to participate in forums again. I think you should have no problems with Herzog - I'm a far less competent reader, and I think you'll enjoy it.
 
Hi DS, glad you are back.

The story revolves around one Moses E Herzog, who at the point of the story has come out from his second marriage. The divorce ended badly, and his now ex-wife, Madeleine, shacked up with his supposedly best buddy Valentine, and he's pissed. Also, amidst this emotional turmoil he's suddenly consumed with remorse over the fact that his second child Junie will be growing up without him. All this culminates in a scene where he attempts to confront Maddy when he learned that Junie was apparently mistreated during an argument with Valentine. The manner of his attempted confrontation and subsequent fallout from that forms the climax of the novel.

That's a great summary -- in an overall a great review. It makes me put the book back onto my teetering to-read stack.

Peder, it's always great to see you. I'm well, but have been quite busy with work. Although that has tapered down somewhat, and I'm free to participate in forums again. I think you should have no problems with Herzog - I'm a far less competent reader, and I think you'll enjoy it.

Busy at work is always a good thing -- much better than the alternative of no work. But not better than actual retirement. I'm enjoying my time here reading, relaxing and putting together a memoir and some poetry. My time is finally my own to enjoy with wife and children. YAY!

As far as being a "less competent reader": Oh pish, and fiddle! See my first comment in this post. :D

Great review, so this time I'll persevere through the tedium.
Many thanks
Peder
:flowers:
 
Back
Top