• Welcome to BookAndReader!

    We LOVE books and hope you'll join us in sharing your favorites and experiences along with your love of reading with our community. Registering for our site is free and easy, just CLICK HERE!

    Already a member and forgot your password? Click here.

Across The Nightingale Floor

Fistandantilus

New Member
nightingalefloor.jpg

What do you think of this book?
 
Ooh, haven't seen that cover before!

I liked it. Across the nightingale floor better than the others, anyway. The extent of death did get to me after a while, but I thought they were really good, and I enjoyed them. They were different... interesting.

not my favourite series the author has written, but probably much better than all her other works.
 
Assassin

I think thant the amount of death in the books is necessary; its not just the book being grusome, I think that it is all down to the fact that Takeo is an assassin
 
Fistandantilus said:
I think thant the amount of death in the books is necessary; its not just the book being grusome, I think that it is all down to the fact that Takeo is an assassin
Hm... funny that.

Though Takeo isn't really an assassin... Have you read the others?
 
i have read across the nightengale floor and grass for his pillow. i was waiting for 3 to come out in paper back which it now has but when i go to buy it, it is always out. i'm just going to order it.
i loved them. i love that hearn has taken historical japan and made it his own by fictionalizing it.(is that a word?) i think they are really well written and i don't mind the violence at all. i find them hard to categorize as they do seem to fall into fantasy, but they would still appeal to people who maybe don't read fantasy.
 
jenngorham said:
i have read across the nightengale floor and grass for his pillow. i was waiting for 3 to come out in paper back which it now has but when i go to buy it, it is always out. i'm just going to order it.
i loved them. i love that hearn has taken historical japan and made it his own by fictionalizing it.(is that a word?) i think they are really well written and i don't mind the violence at all. i find them hard to categorize as they do seem to fall into fantasy, but they would still appeal to people who maybe don't read fantasy.

The author is female... :p
I don't particularly mind all the violence, but the extent of it is the only thing I don't love in the books. After reading all three in a row, it was a bit of an overdose...
 
I really enjoyed all three books, and was glad the series didn't end in the way I thought it would. Some of the violence was a bit stomach-churning for me (I am a wimp!), but I didn't think it was gratuitous - it all made sense in the context of the Japanese culture.

Herenya - I didn't realise she had written other books. I believe Lian Hearn is a pen-name, so are the others under a different name? I would be interested in reading more of her work.
 
She writes children's books under her real name which I suddenly can't remember. :(
Anyway, I thought Across the Nightingale Floor was generally quite average. Apart from the Japanese style setting which seemed almost gimmicky because of its lack of detail and relevance there was very little to set it apart from the usual Fantasy novel. The prose was simple and I found something quite jarring about the writing style.
Her characters were fairly basic stereotypes and I found the way they acted in some situations to be incredable and simpy designed to somehow make the whole thing a "tragedy" and instead made it seem contrived.
However, despite all that, I did enjoy the novel and don't regret purchasing it (though I won't be following the rest of the series).
 
i didn't realize the author was female. cool. i literally stumbled on the first book. it was an advance readers copy at the bookstore i worked in and i slipped on it.

gillian rubenstein(sp?)
 
jenngorham said:
i literally stumbled on the first book. it was an advance readers copy at the bookstore i worked in and i slipped on it.

gillian rubenstein(sp?)

:D

I'll try looking up that name, thanks. :)
 
I've known about Gillian Rubenstein for a while (Lian is just the last part of her first name - clever, huh?) and I knew that her next book would be called "Across the Nightingale Floor."
I'd say that everything else she'd written is pretty much children's. But I love Galax-Arena!!! and I can't wait for her to publish Universercus! I wish she would hurry up...
 
I have this book on my To Be Read list, I've been meaning to read it for ages..have the same cover but in gold and white colour scheme. I may read it sooner than I intended now since it seems like people are pretty positive about it.
 
I finished this surprisingly quick read last week and really enjoyed it. The Japanese style was refreshingly different in a fantasy-genre novel, and it reminded me a lot of the Kelawan world in Feist's Riftware saga. I didn't find the violence at all disturbing, and thought it quite tame to others in this genre, although
when they cut off Lord Shigeru's head that was a bit graphic
. The ending was a little unconventional -
I love it when an author is not afraid to do away with some beloved characters
and I thought the character backgrounds were really interesting, but not as well developed as I would have liked.
I was particularly disappointed that the nature of the Hidden was not explored further
. Perhaps that will come in later books.

I didn't think the first person style worked given that part of the book was through the eyes of Kaede and it seemed to interupt the flow of the book. But I think the first person was necessary to get a good idea of Takeo's thought processes.

Finally, I think the book needed a map to fully understand the layout of the place.

For all of this critique, though, I really did enjoy the book. Great escapism!
 
All the books in this series, The Tales of the Otori, were excellent. I really enjoyed them.
Don't worry, you'll see more of the Hidden in Grass for His Pillow and Brillance of the Moon. Their story is the tale of the Christians in Japan, which is a parallel to the country's drive into modernism, explored the most in the 3rd book.
 
WoodenCoyote said:
Their story is the tale of the Christians in Japan, which is a parallel to the country's drive into modernism, explored the most in the 3rd book.
So is this book somewhat historically based?? This hadn't occurred to me... Please use spoiler tags if necessary. I don't want to have any details revealed :).
 
Kookamoor said:
So is this book somewhat historically based?? This hadn't occurred to me... Please use spoiler tags if necessary. I don't want to have any details revealed :).
Its hardly a spoiler. I knew who the Hidden were by the end of book one. Heck, their names alone were a big hint.

Otori is set on a made-up island in Japan, so the author has a little more freedom. But it is historically based.
 
WoodenCoyote said:
Its hardly a spoiler. I knew who the Hidden were by the end of book one.
No, no. I just meant in future :eek: . Slap me silly, but the Hidden representing Christians never occured to me in the first book.
 
Back
Top