Recent content by CarlosTheTackle

OK, OK. No worries. I thought a spoiler warning in my subject would do, but obviously the rules are a little different here. Now I know. (P.S. Surely in a Book of the Month discussion one would expect contributers to have read the book? Just wondering.)

The thing I love about the Sil is that it makes LOTR so much better. You really have a sense of the history and that makes the sadness of the passing of the Elves in LOTR so much more poignant. And bittersweet endings are always better, IMO.

Some questions about the book (book spoilers) Ok, a couple of questions: 1. Was it ever established that Please note: I haven't read the sequels yet, so if this turns out to be of significance later on then please don't spoil it for me. Just let me know that it does. 2. Was anyone else...